Week 13—Classic vs. Dynamic Baroque

Classic versus Dynamic Baroque in Rome

    • Bernini considered very conservative—particularly in architectural projects
    • Perception of Baroque architecture is often misconstrued because of restorations during the time

Pietro Berrettini da Cortona (1596-1669)

    • 2 years older than Bernini—he too had a long career
    • Like Bernini: extremely versatile: architect, painter, sculpture designer, decorator
    • received much less representation than Bernini or Borromini


Villa Pigneto (1629, destroyed), for Marcello Sachetti

    • Marcello Sacchetti
      • painted by Pietro ad Cortona
      • elegantly and simply expresses the status of the patron as well as showing his interest in antique architecture
    • known by the Patron as Villa Sacchetti
    • painting since the building was destroyed
    • incorporates numerous motifs from the High Renaissance and Late Renaissance in a composition that takes advantage of the site
    • clearly a pleasure villa, not a villa farm

1629—death of Cardinal Moderno


Restoration of Palestrina (Praeneste), for Barberini

      • began getting commissions for sculpture repairs
      • went from Sachetti circle to Cardinal circle…sometime during the 1630s
      • composed of terraced ramps…reminiscent of the Nicchione in the Belvedere Courtyard
        • oversized idea
        • villa setting, in which the fountains leading up to it also reference Villa Farnese
          • Pentagonal Villa with Carriage Ramp and Stairs leading up either side with water features
      • References garden architecture but takes it up to a whole new scale


Glorification of Urban VIII Reign, Barberini Palace

    • cornice, window accents, etc…represent the building
    • illusionistic situation on the ceiling creates a pergola type space (with the leaves and what-not wrapping around it)
    • entire scene is painted from an angle…so standing right underneath it will not give it the correct perspective. the angle of taking a photograph is better from one end
    • approach to allegory is very similar to that of the Baldachin
      • Barberini and their coat of arms—art meeting nature…family coat of arms, Barberini Shield with bees…etc…
      • Now it looks as though they’re flying through the sky being held up by certain virtues


Martina e Luca, 1635-64

    • important both personally and professionally
    • assisted by contacts in Barberini circle
    • originally from 7th century as a chapel dedicated to martyr aniras
      • was not made to fit a congregation
      • dedicated churches tended to be smaller and allow for centralized plans
    • first academy of the arts (Academy of St. Luke)—became a model for development of academies throughout Europe
      • association initially founded to help grow artists
      • resource that funded competitions and assisted artists to find commissioners
      • Cortona was elected art director
    • decided to turn it into a tomb…found corpse of more martyrs, so the chapel was then blessed by the Pope
    • on the Northeast corner of the Roman Forum
    • under-remarked about superb sense of Urban Siding….look at what is surrounding the building
      • only possible orientation is to create a facade visible from the street that turns…so he designs a compact facade that is still monumental (2-story tabernacle) with a very high, elevated dome that adds an additional 2 stories.
      • extremely visible because it is the tallest building in the city
      • projecting end bays with paired pilasters that angle in and create a recessing area
      • very slight projections throughout…elegant and effective use of nude drama (breathing architecture)
        • flat pilasters to engaged columns…drama to the way that it is plastic
        • 2-story tabernacle clearly marked by a strong horizontal element that enforces undulation more

Director of Academia di S. Luca, crypt


S. M. della Pace, 1656-58 

    • shows off Cortona’s qualities as an architect dealing with elements of Urban fabric
    • right next to Piazza Navonna….very crowded
    • also already existed…cloister (Bramante)
    • Cortona was commissioned to create facade and piazza in 1656
    • built as a votive for praying to the Virgin of Peace against the Plague (built during a time when they’re dealing with victory over the french….so it would be visited by the pope and other dignitaries)
    • no longer walking around on foot…now driving around in carriages
      • very narrow alley with no space for a carriage to proceed towards the church or turn around to leave
    • solution is graceful and masks the alley-like condition with a 2-story facade close to Bernini’s S. Andreo Quirinale
    • paired columns insinuate entrance through center bay
    • arms on side have concave, projecting elements that make the sides both look like wings with a unified composition…yet the urban elements are made coherent by the architect
    • undulating facade with two separate characters within each story (interesting way to make facade more complex)
    • use of projecting elements make the facade evident no matter the angle you approach it from (great solution)…also makes it look very large and dynamic (at end of street)
    • created a trapezoidal space that looks nice in the area….creates a theatrical element

Francesco Borromini (1599-1667)

    • samilar age, similar longevity
    • link to cardinal’s nephew brought him to Rome
    • father was an architect- so training received was closer to preparation imagined today—neither Cortona’s or Bernini’s father would’ve given similar training
    • begins as a stone carver—worked on St. Peters when Moderno was the head Papal Architect
    • amazing graphsman—Moderno used him to create drawings for projects for other architects
    • very little freedom in the projects because he was just an assistant
    • personality compared to Michelangelo’s—compared to Corrachi? (painter)


S. Carlo alle Quattro Fontane, 1634-44 cortile, 1638-41 church, 1662-67 façade

    • executed in multiple phases
    • represents some of the earliest and latest work (facade is later)
    • operated by barefoot spanish trinitarians (mission was to collect money to free captured christians)
    • part of larger Barberini neighborhood—commissioned by Barberini as well
    • cloister
      • plan gives a sense of the confined space he was working with
      • compare to Bramante’s cloister in S.M. della Pace (square/rectangle)
        • treatment is similar to that of a rectangle, but he creates an oval feeling with the arches and niches…so the shape feels less closed off—flows better with continuous movement
      • similar to S. Andrea (Vignola)
      • each element forms a motif— Palladian Window Motif (seen previously on flat facades)
        • allows him to manipulate any awkward spaces with columns
        • the lentil curves out giving a concave/convex feeling…undulates the space
        • balusters on second level are also very interesting….they’re alternating right-side-up and upside-down
      • manages to create a space with a lot of movement and likeness
    • church, 1662-67
      • thinking of the facade during the construction of the interior
      • utilizes greater space and elaborate ornament of the interior to accentuate similar qualities of active, organic movement we see in the plan.
      • centralized plan with direction
        • take a circle and use an oval to create direction
      • overall church is rectangular feeling…a pinched rectangle
      • probably used geometric shapes to create measurements and proportions throughout the space

Leave a comment